top of page

Avoiding Publishing Scams & Identifying Reputable Publishers




In the exciting journey from manuscript to published book, authors face numerous challenges, one of which is the risk of falling prey to scam publishers. Recently, we've received troubling news from a few of our clients who were approached by dubious entities making grand promises. These scam publishers assured our authors that their books would not only be traditionally published but also adapted into films — an alluring prospect, indeed.


As a member of the Alliance of Independent Authors, we feel a responsibility to arm our authors with information to protect their dreams and their wallets. This post will guide you through identifying reputable publishers, avoiding publishing scams, and offering advice for successfully publishing and marketing your books.


Avoiding Publishing Scams:

  1. Beware of Flattery and Promises of Fame: Scammers often lure authors with flattery and unrealistic promises. Remember, legitimate agents and publishers are selective and will be candid about the work and the process.

  2. Misleading Claims About Traditional Publishers: Some scam publishers may claim that a traditional publisher is interested in acquiring your book, but you need to secure (and pay for) certain services first — like expensive marketing plans, professional editing, or audiobook format through their agency. Traditional publishers typically cover these costs themselves and do not require authors to pay for services as a precondition for acceptance.

  3. Verify Claims of Adaptations or Bestseller Status: Scammers might promise to turn your book into a movie or guarantee a bestseller status. Such claims should be scrutinized. These achievements require industry connections, and substantial investment is never guaranteed.

  4. Vanity Presses vs. Hybrid Publishing: Understand the difference. Vanity presses will flatter you and charge high prices for minimal services, often producing subpar-quality books. Reputable hybrid publishers provide a range of professional services, charge reasonable fees, and often select their projects carefully.

  5. Consult with a Professional: If you’re uncertain, seek advice from a literary agent, an attorney experienced in publishing, or a seasoned author.


Identifying Reputable Publishers:

  1. Research, Research, Research: Before committing to any publisher, do your homework. Check their track record by simply searching their company on Google or BBB, see who they've published, and look up reviews from other authors.

  2. Assess Their Online Presence: Legitimate publishers invest in a professional online presence. Be cautious of publishers with poorly designed websites, broken links, or social media accounts with little to no engagement.

  3. Check Affiliations and Memberships: Credible publishers often belong to recognized industry organizations like the Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLI), the Independent Book Publishers Association (IBPA), or regional equivalents.

  4. Look for Success Stories: A publisher's backlist can tell you a lot. If they have a history of successful titles or authors, it's a positive indication.

  5. Seek Author Testimonials: Established publishers have authors who can vouch for them. Try to connect with their authors to inquire about their experiences.


Yes, getting traditionally published or having your book adapted into a movie after self-publishing is certainly possible, though it can be challenging and requires strategic effort and sometimes a bit of luck. Here's how these scenarios can happen:


Transitioning from Self-Publishing to Traditional Publishing:


Prove Your Book’s Marketability:

  1. Sales Numbers: Robust sales figures can demonstrate to traditional publishers that your book has a market.

  2. Online Presence: A strong author platform, positive reviews, and an engaged following make you more appealing to publishers.

Literary Agents: Traditional publishers often prefer to deal with literary agents rather than directly with authors. An agent who believes in your self-published book can champion your work to publishers. Again, Literary Agents doesn't require you to invest or secure a service to get Traditionally Published.


Book Awards and Recognition: Winning self-publishing awards or getting notable recognition can catch a traditional publisher's attention.


Getting Your Book Adapted into a Movie:


Established Sales and a Solid Fan Base: Much like traditional publishers, film producers want to see that the story has a market. A successful self-published book with a strong fan base can be attractive.


Networking: Industry connections matter. Screenwriters, directors, and producers are more likely to notice your book if you're putting it in the right hands. Consider attending film festivals, literary events, or screenwriting workshops.


Hire an Agent or Entertainment Attorney: Literary agents with connections in the film industry or entertainment attorneys can help get your book in front of the right people in Hollywood.


Optioning Your Book: Before a book is turned into a film, the film rights must be 'optioned.' This means the producer pays you for the exclusive right to purchase your book’s film rights for a certain period. If a producer shows interest, ensure you have professional representation to negotiate terms.



Publishing can be complex, but with knowledge and the right partners, authors can sidestep scams and move towards success. Atticus Publishing is a proud member of the Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLI), reflecting our commitment to high standards and author empowerment in self-publishing.


Our ALLi membership underscores our dedication to transparency, ethics, and professionalism. We're here to support your journey, offering guidance that respects your work and aspirations.


We're more than a publisher; we're your partner in this literary journey. If you're ready to take the next step but unsure how to proceed, or if you've encountered offers that seem too good to be true, we're here to help.


Don't hesitate. Reach out to us today, and let's work together to turn your publishing dreams into reality. Your story deserves it.


112 views0 comments
bottom of page